Can debating be considered a sport? Well, today that question not debateable. Why? Because I just have to find a way to work "The Great Debaters" into this sports media blog (hat tip to The Starting Five). Having seen it this weekend, I’m telling anyone who will listen to plunk their money down to catch this movie while it is still in the theater. The movie, directed by Denzel Washington, is inspired by the true story of a debating team from all-black Wiley College in Marshall, Texas, in the 1930s. It’s tempting to say that it is "Hoosiers-meets-Akeelah-and-the-Bee-in-Jim-Crow’s-backyard", but that wouldn’t do it justice. If isolated merely as "team underdog story", it is so much better and more important than Hoosiers. There are at least four "Akeelahs" and two compelling mentors (Denzel and Forest Whitaker). If it were simply judged as an "American history" movie depicting life in the Jim Crow south, it excels in its own right by avoiding the tired box office "Ghosts of Mississippi Burning" formula of telling the story through "the white savior" and banging you over the head with "good vs. evil" characters that even a three year old could understand. Instead the viewer is taken through a well-balanced intellectual and emotional journey through life with Mr. Crow, and how those limitations were psychologically navigated by various characters.
The movie also contained beautifully intervoven characters and superb acting by the entire cast. And while 14 year old "Junior" (who depicts a real life and real young James Farmer Jr. – future founder of Congress of Racial Equality) was my favorite character, the one shared scene between Denzel and Forest Whitaker had me begging for an hour-long exchange. Was the outcome of this historically-inspired underdog movie "predictable"? Yes, it was. But so was "Titanic" and I have a sneaking suspicion that a few people were tipped off with the spoiler. But to discuss it simply in the role of “cinema” grossly minimizes the film’s importance. Every American should see this in the theater as it deserves box office dollars even if it doesn’t gross the one billion worldwide like Titanic.
So, in summary, if:
– your friends tell you "why do you have to debate everything", then go see this movie.
– you appreciate great acting and character development, then go see this movie.
– you ever complained about "Jerry Springer" or "Flavor of Love" marking the end of civilization as we know it, then go see this movie.
– you are a high school teacher, take your class to see this movie (it is PG-13).
– you are a parent of a teenager, take them to see this movie.
– you recently paid good money to see Denzel star as NYC drug kingpin Franck Lucas in American Gangster, then go see this movie.
– the last 5 times you saw a movie with a black cast and they were either clowns or criminals, then go see this movie.
– the last 5 times you were overheard complaining about black casts only featured as clowns or criminals, then go see this movie.
– the last 5 times you saw a movie with ANY cast and they were either clowns or criminals, then go see this movie.
– you want more good movies like this to get greenlighted in the future, then go see this movie.
Be the change you want to see in the world — Mahatma Gandhi





MODI, My Brother from another Mother, you arethe sure nuff TRUTH…
You’re right, EVERYBODY should see the Movie. I’m taking my Family Saturday evening.
You go Resident Scholar!
So Modi,
Do you think I should go see this movie?
I will go see this movie.
Saw the movie…..and now I wonder if Denzel is better at acting or directing. This was such great cinema, and the performances by the young actors has me believing Denzel deserves a best director nod!
Modi,
I can’t wait to see this Movie!
I’ll be flying back into NY the 2nd,
I’ll also see it this weekend!
Thanks for the “UPS”
Miranda, you are right. When you consider “Antoine Fisher” was his debut, Denzel is a solid 2 for 2. Besides his penchant for bring real life inspirational stories to the screen, he certainly knows how to bring out the best of young actors.
Exactly Modi…I was thinking of Denzel’s work on Antoine Fisher when I realized just how great of a director he really is. Wasn’t that Derek Luke’s first feature film?? And this was really Denzel Whitaker’s first role (I simply love the irony in his name). I loved Kimberly Elise’s role, as limited as it was. She has the ability to just act with her eyes alone..no words necessary.
yes it was and Derek Luke was excellent. Fair enough about Kimberly Elise’s eyes, but I thought the only acting flaw was that she was underutilized. I think that I would have liked to see an exchange or two from her perspective.
And what about the ongoing battle over which Cinema Houses will show the movie? Some titles just don’t make it to mainstreams theathers due to politics. The Magic Theaters are very helpful in that sense. A special campaing would have to begin right here and now for Denzel to get the necessary ink/air to catapult him to that level. The movie may have suffered due to timing. Still, I believe that it is an immediate classic worthy (like Roots and for “other reasons” A Soldier’s Story) of being purchased for the home video library.
Typos allowed today–the Force MDs from the other blog were serving Henny all night.
Yep, like I said, a limited role, but Kimberly Elise made the most of that small amount of on-screen time. Oh they could have added another hour to the movie and I would have been happy.
Its frustrating though looking up information on the actual members of the debate team and Melvin Tolston…there really isn’t a lot out there.
Steady, good points. And “A Soldier’s Story” doesn’t seem to get its proper due.
Miranda, I was also looking for info on Tolson! I suppose that we are not the only two. He seems to be recognized in history for his poetry more than anything else. I was trying to find a full version of “Dark Symphony” somewhere.
MODI:
With the twins, I won’t be going to see this for a bit, but I did see some exhilarating excerpts on Oprah’s show. Great stuff.
Modi
The wife and I saw the Movie last night.
EXCELLENT! MOVING! STIMULATING TO THE INTELLECTUAL PALLET!
My Son and his Senior class saw it yesterday too in the afternoon, and he and his classmates were invigorated and proud. Ripe minds received good water and nuturing yesterday. Our Leaves of Grass!
This THREAD is a GOOD THING MODI! Many may have allready made up their minds to go, but another push with kindness never hurt anyone.
THANK YOU RESIDENT SCHOLAR!
God Bless You!
Thanks cooley and I’m glad that you enjoyed it. If only we can get more movies like this one…
Hell, if enough people go, we just might…
Hi all! Hot picture alert! If Paris Hilton is your fave, then I have a website for you to see. Who wants it?